# Marcus Obi, Senior Software Engineer at Meridian Financial (320 people) — read of dietary-sensitivity-tracker, June 23 2026

> 8 years writing Go and TypeScript at fintechs, spending nights on side-project research because I keep telling myself this is the year I actually ship something. Lactose intolerant since my 30s, which made me click faster than I should have.

## How I got here

A guy I worked with three years ago, Derek, posted this on LinkedIn with the caption "curious what builders think." I've been lurking Indie Hackers and following a few people who write about micro-SaaS, so the idea hit two nerves at once: I've personally wished an app like this existed, and I'm actively hunting for a product to build on weekends. Clicked through on my lunch break, had maybe 6 minutes.

## What I clicked first

The hero did something right. "No typing. Just talk. Let AI find patterns." is actually a clean value prop. I've tried logging food in MyFitnessPal before and stopped after 4 days because entering individual ingredients is miserable. Voice made immediate sense to me.

Then I saw "Start Tracking Free" and clicked it, expecting a signup flow. Nothing happened, or I missed whatever it does. That was the first moment of friction. I am still not sure if this is a live product or not.

## Where I paused

The line "Works for ethnic cuisines and complex dishes." I stopped there for a second because it is a real and underserved problem. Every food tracker I have used handles "chicken breast and rice" fine and falls apart when I say "my mom made dal makhani with ghee and I had two bowls." That specificity felt like someone had actually thought about the user, not just described an app category. It is the one line that felt written by a person who has lived the problem.

## What I distrusted

After scrolling further I realized this is not actually a product. It is an idea listing. "Adopt the build, $99-$199. Dossier plus the working code starter." That reframing happened slowly and I think I was supposed to notice it before the hero asked me to "Start Tracking Free." Those two things do not belong on the same page without a very clear transition.

Also the scoring is right there in the open: "financial upside: 1/10" and "distribution ease: 3/10." The overall adoptability score is 53/100. I respect the honesty but I am not sure what I am supposed to do with those numbers. Is this the pitch or the disclaimer? The page reads like it is trying to be both at the same time, and it ends up being neither.

"Let AI find patterns" appears in the hero and is never explained once. What AI? How much data before patterns emerge? A week? Three months? What counts as a reaction? These questions are obvious and the page does not address any of them.

## What would convince me

A screen recording of the voice entry flow. Not a polished video, just someone talking into their phone saying "I had a lamb shawarma wrap with garlic sauce around noon and a coffee" and watching it get logged correctly. That one clip would tell me more than the whole page.

Also an honest comparison to Cara Care or MySymptoms. Those exist. They are imperfect. What is the actual delta here beyond voice input? If the answer is "just voice input," that is fine, say that clearly.

## What I'd ask in an email reply

1. The "Start Tracking Free" button in the hero does not go anywhere obvious. Is there a live demo or a prototype, or is the product entirely at the idea stage right now?
2. The code starter in the $99 tier, what stack is it? React Native, Flutter, web app? I want to know before I spend anything whether I am going to spend the next three months fighting a framework I do not know.
3. "Distribution ease: 3/10" is your own score. What specifically makes distribution hard here, and what would a buyer need to already have to overcome that? An existing audience? A partnership with a GI clinic? I want the honest answer, not the optimistic one.

## Verdict: on-the-fence

The underlying idea has real merit and the ethnic cuisine line shows someone thought carefully about who uses this. But the page is genuinely confusing about whether a product exists, and putting a 1/10 financial upside score on the same screen as a buy button is a hard thing to argue with.

---
*Memo by skeptic persona, generated 2026-06-23. Studio breaks own self-grading loop.*