# Marcus Tolliver, Independent Strategy Consultant — read of Brief Generator for Independent Consultants, June 4, 2026

> 11 years total, 4 years solo after leaving a regional strategy firm in Chicago. I coach my daughter's U10 soccer team Saturdays and do all my work from a converted garage with a space heater that sounds like a jet engine.

## How I got here

Googled "consulting project brief template free" after spending 90 minutes writing a scoping doc for a $12K engagement and realizing I was basically rewriting the same 8 sections from scratch again. Found this somewhere in the second page of results, not sure exactly where. Clicked because the headline was direct enough that I didn't immediately close the tab.

## What I clicked first

"Brief Generator creates client-ready briefs from basic project info in 60 seconds." That's a real claim. Sixty seconds. I wrote that down. If it's true, I care. Most of my brief-writing pain is not the thinking part, it's the typing-what-I-already-know-into-a-document part. So this felt like it was aimed at the right thing.

Also stopped at "your brief is your reputation. It's the first thing clients judge you on." That's just true. I've lost at least two engagements where I think the scoping doc looked like I threw it together. So the problem framing landed.

## Where I paused

The Adoptability score section. "66/100 Adoptability. $-13,576 Year-1 take-home (Fermi). 1 in 7 Meaningful-success odds." I read that three times. This is the builder showing me their own internal scorecard on whether this idea is worth building. I have never seen a product page do this. "financial upside: 1/10" is them essentially saying "this probably doesn't make us much money." That's either very honest or it's a trust play designed to make me think they're honest. I don't know which. But I kept reading, which is more than I can say for most pages.

The line "Honest disclosure: we don't have live customers on this idea yet" -- okay. That's a real thing to say.

## What I distrusted

"AI fills in deliverables, timeline, budget framework, and success metrics automatically." I need to see the output. What does a brief actually look like? This page shows me zero examples. Nothing. Not one screenshot of a generated brief, not a sample PDF, not even a mock paragraph. The "Brand Voice" claim is interesting but also completely unverifiable without seeing what the actual output looks like. I've been burned by "sounds like you" tools that produce content that sounds like a LinkedIn influencer from 2022.

Also: "5 hours per month previously spent on brief writing." Where does that number come from? It's specific enough to feel like a stat but vague enough that it could be completely invented. For me it's more like 3-4 hours, so it's roughly in range, but I'd want to know if that's a survey result, a user claim, or just a number someone typed.

The whole page also has this weird dual identity. Am I looking at a product I can use, or am I looking at a business idea I can buy and build myself? The $5/$99/$199 tiers and "Adopt the build" language suggests the latter, but the "Start Creating Briefs Today / 14-day free trial" button suggests the former. I'm genuinely confused about what I'm actually being sold here.

## What would convince me

Show me a before and after. Give me a real brief output from a project description of maybe 3 sentences. Let me read it and judge whether it looks like something I'd actually send a client, or whether it looks like something that would make a client think I'm outsourcing my thinking to a chatbot.

If "Brand Voice" is real, show me two briefs from the same project description -- one generic, one after a brand voice is configured. That's the whole pitch. If you can show me that, I'm interested.

A consultant who actually used it saying something specific like "I sent this to a $25K engagement and it went to SOW the same week" is worth more than any score or Fermi estimate.

## What I'd ask in an email reply

1. Is this a working product I can trial right now, or is it still in build phase? The "no live customers" disclosure and the "Adopt this idea" framing make me genuinely unsure.

2. What does the output actually look like for a mid-sized strategy engagement -- say, a 3-month operational review for a 50-person company? Can you send me a sample?

3. The "Brand Voice" feature -- how does it work in practice? Do I paste in past writing samples, fill out a form, something else? How long does it take to configure?

## Verdict: on-the-fence

The problem is real and the honesty about the product's own limitations is unusual enough to keep me here. But the page shows me zero of the actual work product, which is the entire thing I'd be paying for.

---
*Memo by skeptic persona, generated 2026-06-04. Studio breaks own self-grading loop.*